People think Chloe is better than Maddie, and Chloe cares about dance more. And, Chloe's better but you can't tell because she is getting less practice. But some people, think that Maddie is a stronger dancer, and uses more emotions, which one do you think? Comment below!
they are both amazing dancers, i feel like maddie is better because as rumored and obvious melissa has been taking maddie and kenzie to privates. Chloe is so underappreciated she is just as amazing as maddie she just needs a boost of cofidence instead of negativity if she had more positive influences she'd be less pressured and could focus more on the actual dancing. Abbey puts a lot of pressure on chloe to be better than maddie and she always ends up being second to maddie and at this point i'm not sure if it's real contest reasults or scripted.
I honestly think Chloe. I always hear "all the dancers think Maddie is better and all the non-dancers think Chloe is better". Well, I used to dance, and I still remember a lot of things, and I just think Chloe has more emotion and technique.
I was so upset with Abby tonight didn't think she would stoop this low...shame on her...Chloe acted with class can't say that about Abby Lee.....don't think her father would have been proud of her tonight....Pam
Chloe has emotions that look real and Maddie kind of looks like she's trying too hard. I think Maddie has the ability to stay calm while Chloe sort of psychs herself out. It makes Maddie appear more prepared and in general better. I think they are both amazing and personally I like Chloe a little more (although I am a dancer). I don't know why, maybe it's her personality or maybe it's because she's the underdog, but I love Chloe!
Chloe is very great. So is Maddie! :)! But really, I think that Maddie is better. Maddie is like if she has a theme she will stick to it. But on the other hand Chloe is more like, let's say her theme is a devil who wants to get back to an angel, we can't really tell if she is she is an angel or devil!
I'm currently a dancer and it seems to me that in all Chloe is a better dancer. She can do more styles- jazz, lyrical, musical theatre and ballet but Maddie usually sticks with lyrical and contemporary.
As a former dancer myself, I appreciate both girls' talents. However, I do believe Chloe more when it comes to telling the story in her dances - her technique and her acting ability are very impressive for someone her age.
defieneltely Chloe. Maddie is very very good at what she does - Tap & lyrical. But I think tbh, Abby must not have much faith in her cos she never allows her to branch out & try other styles as she is afraid she will lose - Abby may think she is helping Maddie 'cos maddie always wins & will have a good reputation - but to be a dancer in LA you MUST be good at hiphop, jazz, modern etc. and in the end it doesn't really matter if you're good a lyrical & nothing else. You can tell Abby is deliberately trying to stop chloe winning by giving her styles which she isn't familiar with - but I would love to see Abby's face in 10years time when chloe & Maddie audition for a comercial dance role - and chloe gets it because she never bothered to teach Maddie how to beat her with anything but lyrical & tap.
and By the way I am a comercial dancer in LA so I know EXACTLY what it takes to do it & I have seen so many girls who thought they were gods gift b/c they had won "this many" titles doing lyrical/ballet & boy did they get a shock when they walked into the audition and found that the judges could care less if they could do 20+ pirouettes if they couldn't dance hip-hop & jazz - NEWSFLASH in how many justin biebers concert, or selena gomez music videos have you seen ballet dances?
Honestly, no. Chloe has better turns, wins pretty high with out any practice, and deals with pressure every week and doesn't crack. Maddie wins because she practices her solo abajillion times. Not fair. I like Chloe.
(I'm not hating, this is my opinion.) Chloe has better turns because they're smooth and clean. I don't think Maddie's turns are that good because they're pretty wobbled, Maddie needs to work on her balance. Maddie sickles her feet when she turns, and Chloe doesn't. Maddie does the same thing... lyrical. Chloe does different genres. Maddie wins because Abby gives her better choreography and Abby gives Chloe awful choreography. I'm not hating, I'm just saying.
I dance. chloe has the perfect phisique, perfect lines, flexible, her turns are amazing and her teqnig=que is tied with brooke, who i would argue as the second best dancer. overall, chloes the right choice.
I think Chloe's the better dancer, but Maddie's quite good in her own way. Unfortunately, I also think that Maddie should stick to tap and things - she's the only one in the group who can, apparently,do tap at all, so I think if Melissa wants Maddie to be the best, she shouldn't be doing much ballet (which is Chloe's strong suit) or acro (which is basically everybody else's strong suit) or jazz (which is apparently Kendall's strong suit). Tap is Maddie's strong suit.
Both are excellent dancers in their own way, and they both showcase their different strengths. Maddie has more of a "Broadway" style of dancing, and Chloe's graceful extensions and the like makes her fit with a ballerina-like style. While both are very technical, however, I feel that the best type of dancer is one who is great in technique and has plenty of passion, which makes Maddie the better dancer. Not saying that Chloe doesn't have emotion, but if she were to boost her confidence level and own it like Maddie, she would be just as good, or even better.
(sorry didn't finish) and ballet, but Maddie is better at tap and lyrical. Chloe is better at turns and portraying characters, but Maddie is better at leaps and always smiling. It's so hard to decide because they are both great dancers! :)
They are both really good, but in my opinion Maddie is better. She just has that dedication and work ethic and wants to be there. I'm not saying Chloe doesn't, I know she does, but she missed Nationals this year for vacation. Plus, Maddie is just a little bit stronger and more powerful with her movements. Chloe is more angelic and a little softer and slower.
I'm sick of saying my opinion about this. Your sick of hearing :There both amazing! I think Chloe has the look to make it in the professional world. I think Maddie has the skill. Maddie taps. Sure, so does Chloe but Maddies better. Whens the last time you saw a lyrical dancer on broadway? I think there both amazing and they can both make it in their own way.
I feel so bad for both girls they are great dancers but how can Abby sleep at night knowing she is constatenly MADDIE and not Chole. I wonder how Maddie really feels mentally when Abby is constantly putting her above everyone else, like they are HER second class citizens. And how do the other girls really feel about Maddie always being made the GOD of the studio. I see fear in their eyes when all the yelling is going on, they are children! Abby expectes them to tell their moms to take a flying leap and disobey their moms and their decisions. Abby is the real problem here, she is so busy trying to control the moms that she is punshing and using the kids as pawns, she reallly has a mental problem. How sad, she really does produce winners but she could still do this because she is very talented in that direction with out all this abuse, and it is abuse. What are they all teaching these children???
I think that Abby likes the zeigler family better and she is angry at Chloe because she won a national title OVr maddie last year.. I think Abby has been punishing Chloe for,winning. I think that if Chloe had been second last year and Maddie had won that Abby would have treated Ahloe "better". I think Abby is in 'love' with Maddie in some kind of weirdo way.. Watch the way she stares at her and Abby's tounge hangs out of her moth when she obsessively gawky at Maddie. her behavior is not natural or professional toward this child. That's what I see on my TV screen anyway.
SORRY FOR THE COMMENTNTHEYRE ALL ACTING ACCORDING TO PRE AGREED PLOT. IT'S A TV SHOW!!!!!!! THEY NT PEOPLE TO GET UPSET TO CRETE RATINGS. SORRY FOR THE COMMENTS. IT'S LIKE COMMENTING ON AN EPISODE OF THE FLINTSTONES. !!!! IT'S A SILLY SHOW. DO PEOPLE BELIVE THIS STUFF IT'S. PUT ON. THE KIDS KNOW IT THEY RE ALL!PAID TO!PLAY A PART. IT'S A SHOW. SOON SORRY ABBY'S A GREAT GAL. JUST PLAYING HER PART IN THE SHOW
Well I think Chloe is a better dancer because she can do lots of styles of dance, while Maddie can only do lyrical and tap. When Maddie was given Jazz she not only lost to Chloe but also came 3rd place instead of 2nd. She also forgot a contemporary routine and later when performing it only placed 2nd when the music skipped too. Doing a Spanish jazz routine she fell out of a front aerial, placing 3rd (not shown) behind Chloe and Paige. Even when Maddie performed tap she placed 3rd and 2nd only. I am not saying this because I hate Maddie, which I don't, I actually get to talk to her once a month and am very lucky to get that oppertunity for a canadian fan, but I am saying this because I think Chloe is a better dancer. Chloe did win 1st place for when Maddie and herself performed the smae solo, but her score was "supposedly" incorrect. Anyway so I think Chloe.
I noticed someone else posted this but I find myself becoming distracted with Maddie dancing due to the look on her face. It's the same look she uses for all her dances - which is a look of constipation. It's difficult to watch.
I just carefully looked at YouTube comparing both. Chloe has long beautiful lines. Mad die has short chubby limbs. While both perform. The lines of Chloe are more professional and mad dies are short and stubby kind of cute for a little kid but not for a professional unless Marie gets a whole lot taller. Hmmmm. While short and stubby is nice for gymnastics.. Eg Olympics. It's not the lines for ballet or dance..... Maybe Abby sees herself in Madie? As the dancer who never succeed on stage because of body type? In the long run so she become a teacher to prove herself? Is that what it is? Who knows but from an objective view. Cause I don't know any of these folks I'd say that over time and growth.... Chloe has the lines to be a professional. And Madie will out grow her competitiveness when she remains short and short legs etc... I don't know it's a guess. But there is preferential treatment... Look at all entertainment industry...it's who you know... Not necessarily talent. It's promotion... Look at frank Sinatra. Not a handsome dude.... But success came with promotion and media... Go to the opera there's hundreds of great singer song writers. The ones that succeed are just in the right place etc... So who's better dancer? Chloe no doubt.. But Abby keeps saying Maddie is because she wants her to be so she's promoting her. What would the Joffrey balet say? I bet I know!
Because thats what their children want, to be a professional dancer. I feell that even though Chloe has beautiful lines and is a great dancer, Maddie has just as good as a shot to get on Broadway. Think- whens the last time you saw a lyrical dancer on broadway. It's mostly tap with some comptemporay and acrobatics ( of coarse there are exceptions)
Maddie is better than Chloe, if you compare their ages. Maddie is 10 and Chloe is 12. When Chloe was 10 she couldn't dance as good as Maddie. I actually think Abby puts more pressure on Maddie than Chloe...Maddie is given solos every week and Abby expects her to win 1st place consistenly. If Christi wanted Chloe to be the favourite, she should have paid for privates like Melissa does. Both of then are good but Maddie is a more well rounded dancer- she can do tap, lyrical, contemporary, jazz, ballet and even hip hop. Acrobatics is something she is not too good at. Chloe is not good at lyrical, tap, acrobatics and hip hop. And in the episode Two Girls One Solo, Chloe originally won but it turns out that there was a miscalculation and the Maddie won instead. Plus tap hardly ever comes first and Maddie must be really good to even place because face it, judges prefer lyrical/ contemporary
22.214.171.124 wrote: People think Chloe is better than Maddie, and Chloe cares about dance more. And, Chloe's better but you can't tell because she is getting less practice. But some people, think that Maddie is a stronger dancer, and uses more emotions, which one do you think? Comment below!
Maddie cares more about dance, not Chloe. Maddie was willing to be homeschooled to get more dance time in, that shows commitment. It is Abbys job to teach them the routine, not her job to nag at then to practice. So if Chloe really cared, she would have practised.
I am a dancer. Chloe definitely has the better technique, her lines and alignment are very good and her turns are amazing apart from the odd funky arm. I think Maddie has better facial expressions. As a ballerina I think Chloe should be at ballet school/ ballet program as she has a natural gift!
I am being honest Chloe has better technique but abby just slaps together something and throws her on stage chloe said she learns a solo in 45 minutes thats why she loses maddie probely learns a solo in 1 hour the judges mostly looks at faces of the dance your doing thats why maddie always wins
i'm not a dancer, but i think dance is about more than just technique. maddie's faces seem a bit forced. chloe on the other hand dances with pure emotion that comes from her and not what abby says to do. remember she won the award for having the best emotion. i think emotion is what connects with ppl because most ppl don't dance (like me) and don't notice most technical flaws. don't take my opinion as anything though.... i really know nothing on the topic. to me chloe is just an overall more beautiful dancer and given the oppurtunities maddie gets, i think she would really shine even more
As the Joffrey judge said in Season 1, Maddie is a performer, and Chloe is a ballerina/dancer - Maddie is amazing, as is Chloe, but they are exceptional in two different ways :)
Also, before anyone tells me that Maddie also won a Joffrey scholarship, it was for Modern Dance, not Ballet, so Chloe's technique is judged to be better.
Maddie's faces, I think, are a little over the top now, and her solos are always the same, which is why she seems to pick up so quickly - Abby just gives her the same with a slight variation - just like with group dances (every time, Maddie is featured, does turns while the others dance around her, then, at the end, the other girls all leave the stage or lie on the floor while she turns) - I think that if Abby mixed it up like she does to Chloe, Maddie may not place 1st all the time, but she would be a better dancer :)
They are good in there own ways. People should stop comparing them. They are 2 different girl, they may have similar dancing styles but they are complettly different. It is wrong for one girl to be growing up in anothers shadow. By comparing them both and by saying which one is better is lowering there self esteem.
They are both so AWESOME!!!! Maddie is incredible at almost anything just as chloe they are so good dancers just like the rest of the girls. Everyone compares them when they don't realize that they are alike in almost everything, they are 1 in a million. They might be different in many stuff like schools or apperance or their height but; when they start to dance the act like one dance dancer not like two seperate groups. :)
Chelsea They are both so AWESOME!!!! Maddie is incredible at almost anything just as chloe they are so good dancers just like the rest of the girls. Everyone compares them when they don't realize that they are alike in almost everything, they are 1 in a million. They might be different in many stuff like schools or apperance or their height but; when they start to dance the act like one dance dancer not like two seperate groups. :)
I think the both of them are just amazing but maddie can be better sometimes and Chloe can be better but maddie does the same stuff like the spins but she can do more but nobody would know but Chloe does different things and I think Chloe got a little more
Chloe is my personal favorite to watch, but I think they are both amazing and should not be compared. I really enjoy watching them both, and I love it when they have duets! <3 I really don't see why one has to be better than the other. They both have their strengths and weaknesses. Neither of them are perfect, but who is? :)
To be honest I think that Chloe is better it's just that there compared a lot I really kind of don't like how Abby favors Maddie though it's kind of rude cuz all of the girls r good dancers they couldn't be compared. Since they r I think that Chloe is better she's my fav dancer and Paige.
Both. If they had same amount of time. Watch their duets and you will be amazed with what they do. It lookes like 1 person is on the stage dancing. They look professional. So for this one,I have
No answer. If you think why am I even answering, I like to do it for fun.
My personal opinion is that they shine in very different areas. Chloe seems very self-contained to me - she has amazing self control and an air of solemnity about her, which makes her perfect for portraying dark characters, such as she did in her and Maddie's duet Black Swan and her solo The Raven. Her containment and control also aid her natural ability at ballet. Then she also shines in musical theater and contemporary, which is excellent for her career choice (I believe Chloe wants to be a Rockette or to dance on Broadway). She has even won in jazz, as seen with her Black Heart solo. Maddie is not as self-contained - she has so much emotion and passion just flowing from her, and is excellent at portraying emotional characters. She certainly tries very hard at being emotional when she dances, perhaps a bit too hard, but she has that spark that makes her very good at telling a story. However, the only kind of dance she really shines in is lyrical, which is probably why most of her solos are in that genre. I don't actually think tap is a strong suit of Maddies - I have never seen her win in it; she only gets 2nd and 3rd place with her tap solos. She also tends to not get first with contemporary and jazz solos, among other genres of dance. However, she is very consistent with placing first when she performs lyrical dances. Unfortunately, although Maddie is amazing at lyrical, I don't believe there are many career options for lyrical dancers. I do see her getting better at ballet in Season 4, but I just can't see Maddie as a professional ballerina. She seems like she would be better suited to being on Broadway or in music videos, but she doesn't shine in the dance types utilized in those careers. Thus, I think they are equally good dancers in their respective fields, but I do believe Chloe will have a better chance of becoming a professional dancer. I'm sorry this has gone on so long!
If Chloe got as much attention form abby that maddie gets.Chloe would be better by miles.I dont realy see whats so great about maddie she is nothing compared to sophia lucy or chloe. plus chloe is a national title holder.
Hoopsgirl29 wrote: They are both really good, but in my opinion Maddie is better. She just has that dedication and work ethic and wants to be there. I'm not saying Chloe doesn't, I know she does, but she missed Nationals this year for vacation. Plus, Maddie is just a little bit stronger and more powerful with her movements. Chloe is more angelic and a little softer and slower.
She didn"t go on a vacation she wasn't aloud to perform becuase Christi and Peyton's mum got in a fight !
In my opinion Chloe is better. She can do most themes unlike Maddie who is only good at Tap,Lyrical. Maddies face is fake and she tries to hard while Chloe is more relaxed which makes her beautifull but thats just my opinion
honestly i don't quite understand why so many of you are saying maddie has a constipated face when she dance, tries too hard,etc.. and chloe has a more pure expression coming from the heart..
trust me, from the judge point of view ( in front of the stage ) maddie's expressions is very appreciated. exaggerating your expressions is NEEDED on stage.
to me, it only sounds like maddie is being professional and knows that she need to exaggerate her expressions to do onstage while chloe has a more subtle expression on stage(and hardly noticed sometimes). --> this leads to maddie having A SENSE OF PRESENCE. of course, chloe's expression is more attractive to the viewers on internet as the camera ZOOMS IN ON THE PERSON AND FACE..
i say they're equal if not chloe is a tad better. chloe does have the beautiful lines
chloe is gentler and softer while maddie is stronger.. maddie also has more energy and i truthfully think she is more fluid than chloe even from her first solo in the first season, cry by alexx when she was 8. chloe looks a bit more unsteady as she is bigger in size her legs are longer so it's harder to control her body thus not fluid enough. however chloe is still amazing at control and dark characters.
I strongly believe a dancer would say maddie is the better dancer and non-dancers would say chloe is the better dancer.
I am a dancer..
Maybe it's my style.. I actually like maddie's stronger energy more than chloe's slow, smoothing energy. Chloe is a good dancer, nonetheless
Maddie make me feel like this is exactly how a dancer should behave and act on stage.
And somehow why Chloe has so much more fans is because how the show portray her to be,
A girl who receive no attention from abby, always losing to maddie because she has the 'better choreography' or whatever.. >.<
Maddie is far better dancer. Ithink in season 1 it was difficult to say who was better because they each had different strengths, but Maddie has progressed more than Chloe has. Maddie can dance in more genres than Chloe can, and Maddie has the drive to improve an the natural ability that is going to make her continue to improve, wereas Chloe doesn't seem very motivated.
There should not be comparison between these two dancers and it should be saved for the stage and the stage alone. They're pre-teenagers already rittled with insecurity and self-scrutiny who are privy to a thousand feeds like this one. Society should shun this disgusting show and not feed into things like this. It is going to end in nothing but psychological damage for all girls involved. These mothers should be ashamed that they're subjecting their poor daughters to this crap, and as responsible members of society, we should be nothing but supportive of these girls and remind them how beautiful and talented they are.
Naturally - Chloe. Actually right now - Maddie. Chloe manages to place high with very little tutoring. Abby is practically Maddie's personal dance teacher, so by all accounts she should be better. I think if they received equal time to learn routines and practice, Chloe would beat Maddie regularly. Chloe also looks much more aesthetically pleasing on stage, long limbs, etc. I think Chloe has a confidence problem at times, not helped by her mother's neuroses.
I think they are both good dancers. Maddie has different opportunities and different stresses than Chloe. Maddie gets extra dance classes, instruction and better choreography. Maddie is homeschooled. Chloe goes to school like a normal kid (and please I'm not hating on homeschooled kids so save it) and therefore she has assignments due at school to teachers (not her mom) and it restricts how much time she can be in the dance studio. But lets be honest here, anytime an outside company came in (not recruited by Abby for Maddie) Maddie was not selected. Chloe got both the Joffrey scholarship and the Lux video (which she was AWESOME in!) and Kendall got the magazine cover. Maddie is on top in the studio simply because she is Abby's favorite NOT because she's actually better than Chloe!
I wish Abby would put Chloe in more dark/creepy numbers...she does them so well. The black swan number was one of my favorites!! Maddie could NEVER pull off a number like that (the dark part) because it takes a better actress and Chloe definitely has that down.
I think most people sympathize with chloe just because she's the underdog. I as a dancer think Maddie's just sharper with her movements and her technique is mostly flawless.
Sure her movements are more sharper, I wouldn't say flawless, that's a bit of a reach. Being sharper than other dancers comes with practice and with all of the extra attention and privates Maddie gets she should be sharper than Chloe. I don't think Chloe is an underdog, she's a beautiful dancer as well.
I'm sorry, but people who say that Maddie is better just because she takes more classes, more privates, is home-schooled, etc. are obviously non-dancers. Just because she gets those stuff does not mean she's the better dancer. Chloe can do a lot of genres that Maddie can't do.. she can do tap (I saw a clip of her doing tap), hip-hop, jazz, musical theater, lyrical, contemporary, improv, dark, ballet, etc. Maddie can only do lyrical and tap! Honestly, I don't think Maddie's technique is that good.. I find her technique kinda sloppy and messy. She needs to work on a lot of stuff! She sickles her feet when she turns, she sickled her foot when she did a layout in 'Two Sapphires', she needs to get higher on relevé when she turns, etc. Chloe's turns are amazing and clean! Maddie's turns are kinda sloppy compared to Chloe's. I wish Maddie fans would wake up and realize that Maddie isn't perfect. Chloe isn't perfect either, nobody is! But again, Maddie fans need to realize that. I AM NOT HATING ON MADDIE! She's a good dancer, but I can't stand her fans.